Preview - Kinetic Molecular Theory

The Claim-Evidence-Reasoning Structure


In chemistry class, when we answer a question, we call that answer a "claim". You may have heard this term before, in relation to the explanation structure Claim-Evidence-Reasoning. A claim states the relationship between your independent variable and your dependent variable. You do not provide any data or explanation of why this relationship exists. 

Evidence is data that we gather in class, organized to support a claim. It is important that you realize that the data you record from an experiment in class is not automatically evidence. To produce evidence, you will pull two data points from your raw data to support the relationship stated in your claim. For a lab report, you will be required to compose evidence with multiple data point sets. Quantitative data is prioritized over qualitative data if available.

Reasoning is the explanation of why the data is appropriate (i.e., why is this data relevant?) and how the data support the claim. This is where you explain the science behind why your evidence supports your claim.

You already made a claim to answer the question: "In which temperature water did the food coloring spread faster?" on the previous page. It was clear in the experimental video that the food coloring spread faster in hot water. Below, you will be asked to support that claim with evidence and to explain why your evidence supports that claim with reasoning.


Referenced Questions

These questions were answered in the previous steps. They are provided here for your reference.

Use the stopwatch on your phone to acquire quantitative data for each trial.

Questions

Please answer the questions below.

Write evidence to support the claim that food color moves faster in hot water than it does in cold water using data from the experiment presented on the previous page of this lesson. The data table with averages is referenced above to help you answer this question. Use the format provided below to write your evidence statement.

<Evidence Statement>

According to the text/data table/diagram…  

When (description of IV, independent variable, condition) the (insert qualitative or quantitative description of DV, the dependent variable)


Now explain you evidence using reasoning. Your reasoning should include more than simply rehashing the data from the evidence portion of your explanation.

Particles will move (faster/slower) in a high temperature environment compared to a cold temperature environment, resulting in a (direct/indirect) relationship between particle movement and temperature. In summary, here is how the evidence supports my claim: ... Therefore...

 


Notes

These notes will appear on every page in this lesson so feel free to put anything here you'd like to keep track of.